Under Construction

This page is under construction. Please check back later for comprehensive guidance

Google Workspace Marketplace Security¶

This guide provides security professionals and MSPs with comprehensive strategies for securing Google Workspace Marketplace applications, focusing on the unique challenges of managing third-party application security in multi-tenant environments.

Understanding the Marketplace Security Landscape¶

Marketplace Application Architecture¶

Google Workspace Marketplace applications can integrate with Google services in multiple ways, each with distinct security implications:

OAuth-Based Integration
Applications request specific OAuth scopes
Access persists through user-approved tokens
Can operate with user's permissions across Google services
Add-on Integrations
Context-specific extensions for Gmail, Drive, etc.
Run within specific Google applications
May have deep integration with content and data
Chrome Extensions
Browser-based functionality
Can interact with Google Workspace in the browser context
May have persistent access to user sessions
Apps Script Integrations
Custom code running in Google's infrastructure
Deep integration with Google services
Can create automations and workflows

Critical Security Considerations¶

When managing Marketplace applications, several critical security factors must be addressed:

Existing Installation Challenge
Key issue: Allowlisting doesn't remove previously installed applications
Applications installed before restrictions may retain access
User-level installations may exist across organizational units
Organizational Unit Limitations
Applications can be enabled/disabled at OU level
User movement between OUs impacts application access
Some administrative applications bypass OU controls
Permission Persistence
OAuth tokens may persist despite policy changes
Application access can survive user password changes
Revoking access requires explicit token revocation
Installation Scope Variations
Some apps can only be installed by administrators
Others allow user-initiated installation
Admin-installed apps may have different permission models

Comprehensive Marketplace Security Strategy¶

1. Application Inventory and Audit¶

First, establish complete visibility into your current Marketplace application landscape:

Inventory Current Installations:

# Python script example using Google Admin SDK
from googleapiclient.discovery import build
from oauth2client.service_account import ServiceAccountCredentials

def get_installed_applications(admin_sdk_service):
    """Retrieve all installed Marketplace applications across the organization"""
    # Get all Chrome apps and extensions
    chrome_apps = admin_sdk_service.chromeosdevices().list(customerId='my_customer').execute()
    
    # Get OAuth application grants
    tokens = admin_sdk_service.tokens().list(customerId='my_customer').execute()
    
    # Get Apps Script projects
    # Note: Requires Apps Script API enablement
    # [Implementation details]
    
    return {
        'chrome_apps': chrome_apps,
        'oauth_tokens': tokens,
        'apps_scripts': apps_scripts
    }

# Authentication setup
credentials = ServiceAccountCredentials.from_json_keyfile_name(
    'service-account.json',
    ['https://www.googleapis.com/auth/admin.directory.device.chromeos',
     'https://www.googleapis.com/auth/admin.directory.user']
)
credentials = credentials.create_delegated('admin@domain.com')
service = build('admin', 'directory_v1', credentials=credentials)

# Get inventory
app_inventory = get_installed_applications(service)

Audit Techniques: 1. Compare installed applications against current allowlist 2. Identify previously installed applications that would now be restricted 3. Document application permissions and access scopes 4. Map user-to-application relationships

2. Comprehensive Cleanup Process¶

Address existing installations that don't meet current security requirements:

Admin-Level Cleanup:

Admin Console > Apps > Marketplace Apps > App Management
- Filter for "User-installed apps"
- Select non-compliant applications
- Click "Revoke" to remove access organization-wide

Important: This will revoke OAuth access tokens for selected applications across all users, but requires careful planning to avoid disruption.

Scripted Token Revocation:

name="__codelineno-2-1" href="#__codelineno-2-1"># Python script to revoke specific application tokens class="k">def revoke_application_tokens(admin_sdk_service, client_id): """Revoke all tokens for a specific application client ID""" users = admin_sdk_service.users().list(customer='my_customer').execute() for user in users.get('users', []): user_email = user['primaryEmail'] try: # List tokens for user tokens = admin_sdk_service.tokens().list(userKey=user_email).execute() # Find and revoke tokens for target application for token in tokens.get('items', []): if token.get('clientId') == client_id: admin_sdk_service.tokens().delete( userKey=user_email, clientId=client_id ).execute() print(f"Revoked token for {user_email}") except Exception as e: print(f"Error processing {user_email}: {str(e)}")

Chrome Extension Cleanup:

Admin Console > Devices > Chrome > Apps & Extensions
- Locate non-compliant extensions
- Block installation and force removal

Apps Script Project Audit:

Admin Console > Security > API Controls > Apps Script
- Review and configure Apps Script project settings
- Disable unauthorized Apps Script execution

3. Implementing Proper Application Controls¶

Configure comprehensive controls for Marketplace applications:

OAuth Application Allowlisting:

Admin Console > Security > API Controls > Domain-wide OAuth API Access Control
- Set to "Only allow user access to specific third-party applications"
- Configure "Google Workspace Marketplace Apps control"

Important Considerations: 1. Allowlisting is forward-looking and doesn't affect existing installations 2. Test impact on critical applications before enforcement 3. Document exceptions and justifications

Application Installation Policy:

Admin Console > Apps > Marketplace Apps > Settings
- Choose appropriate installation restrictions:
  - "Only allow installation of selected applications"
  - "Block installation of specific applications"
- Apply settings to appropriate OUs

Chrome Application Management:

Admin Console > Devices > Chrome > Apps & Extensions
- Configure force-installed applications
- Block unauthorized extensions
- Set installation permissions by OU

4. Organizational Unit Application Strategy¶

Develop a structured approach for application management across OUs:

OU-Based Application Profiles: 1. Define application requirements by user function 2. Create OU structure that supports differentiated application access 3. Document required applications for each functional group

OU Transition Procedures: 1. Develop process for handling application access during OU moves 2. Create verification procedures for access changes 3. Implement monitoring for unexpected application behaviors after moves

Handling Administrator-Only Applications: 1. Identify applications that can only be installed by administrators 2. Create approval workflow for admin-level application requests 3. Implement enhanced monitoring for privileged applications

Advanced Marketplace Security Techniques¶

Continuous Application Monitoring¶

Implement ongoing monitoring to detect application security risks:

OAuth Token Activity Monitoring:

-- Example monitoring query for suspicious application activity
SELECT user_email, application_name, client_id, scope_list, 
       request_time, ip_address, user_agent
FROM token_audit_logs
WHERE application_name NOT IN (SELECT app_name FROM approved_applications)
  AND (
    scope_list LIKE '%gmail%' OR
    scope_list LIKE '%drive%' OR
    scope_list LIKE '%admin%'
  )
ORDER BY request_time DESC

Application Behavior Analysis: 1. Establish baseline application activity patterns 2. Monitor for anomalous API call volumes or patterns 3. Track application resource access changes 4. Implement alerts for suspicious authorization requests

Marketplace Application Security Scoring: 1. Develop risk scoring methodology for applications 2. Consider factors like: - Developer reputation - Requested permissions - User base size - Update frequency - Privacy policy quality 3. Use scoring to inform allowlisting decisions

Application Lifecycle Management¶

Implement comprehensive governance for application lifecycle:

Application Acquisition Process: 1. Create standardized request process for new applications 2. Implement security review requirements 3. Document business justification and data access needs 4. Conduct privacy review for user data implications

Periodic Application Review: 1. Schedule quarterly review of approved applications 2. Assess ongoing business need and usage patterns 3. Review permission scopes for potential reduction 4. Validate security posture of critical applications

Application Decommissioning Procedure: 1. Identify unused or deprecated applications 2. Develop communication plan for affected users 3. Create phased removal process to minimize disruption 4. Implement token revocation and access removal 5. Verify complete access termination

Security Control Testing¶

Validate the effectiveness of Marketplace security controls:

Allowlist Bypass Testing: 1. Attempt to install restricted applications in test environment 2. Verify that restrictions apply across acquisition methods 3. Test OU transition scenarios for control persistence 4. Validate admin notification for blocked installation attempts

Permission Escalation Testing: 1. Evaluate approved applications for permission escalation risks 2. Test application behavior when requesting additional scopes 3. Verify notification process for permission changes 4. Validate revocation effectiveness

OAuth Token Persistence Testing: 1. Monitor token persistence after various account actions 2. Verify revocation effectiveness across device types 3. Test token behavior across organizational changes 4. Validate cleanup procedures for terminated users

MSP-Specific Marketplace Security¶

Multi-Tenant Application Management¶

For MSPs managing multiple client environments:

Client-Specific Application Profiles: 1. Develop standard application bundles by client type 2. Create client-specific approval processes 3. Implement isolation between client application environments 4. Document cross-client application considerations

Delegated Application Administration: 1. Configure appropriate delegated controls for client admins 2. Establish clear responsibilities for application management 3. Implement approval workflows for sensitive application changes 4. Create audit capabilities for delegated administration actions

Multi-Tenant Monitoring: 1. Deploy cross-tenant application monitoring 2. Create client-specific application alerts 3. Develop comparative application metrics across clients 4. Implement threat intelligence sharing for application risks

Client Onboarding Application Security¶

Establish structured application management during client onboarding:

Application Discovery Phase: 1. Inventory existing applications before migration 2. Identify business-critical application dependencies 3. Document application integrations and workflows 4. Assess security risks in current application portfolio

Application Migration Strategy: 1. Classify applications by migration priority 2. Develop testing plan for business-critical applications 3. Create contingency plans for incompatible applications 4. Establish timeline for application transition

Post-Migration Verification: 1. Verify application functionality after migration 2. Validate security controls for migrated applications 3. Implement monitoring for application anomalies 4. Document exceptions and special handling requirements

Common Marketplace Security Challenges¶

Challenge 1: Shadow IT Applications¶

Issue: Users install unauthorized applications outside management visibility

Detection Techniques: 1. Regular token audits across the organization 2. Browser extension inventory and monitoring 3. Data access pattern analysis 4. Network traffic monitoring for API calls

Remediation Strategies: 1. Implement technical controls to prevent unauthorized installations 2. Create clear application request process for users 3. Provide pre-approved application catalog 4. Conduct user education on application security risks

Challenge 2: Permission Creep¶

Issue: Authorized applications request additional permissions over time

Detection Techniques: 1. Track scope changes for authorized applications 2. Monitor authorization requests for scope expansion 3. Compare current permissions against initial approval 4. Audit API call patterns for permission usage

Remediation Strategies: 1. Implement scope change approval processes 2. Create alerts for permission expansion requests 3. Conduct periodic permission rationalization 4. Maintain principle of least privilege in approvals

Challenge 3: Application Developer Changes¶

Issue: Marketplace applications change ownership or security posture

Detection Techniques: 1. Monitor application developer information changes 2. Track application update patterns and changes 3. Review privacy policy and terms updates 4. Monitor community feedback and security reports

Remediation Strategies: 1. Implement periodic application re-verification 2. Create quick response process for suspicious changes 3. Maintain application alternatives documentation 4. Develop emergency revocation procedures

Implementation Checklist¶

Marketplace Security Baseline¶

Complete inventory of currently installed applications
Document business justification for each application
Implement application allowlisting policy
Configure OU-based application controls
Revoke access for unauthorized applications
Implement monitoring for application activity
Create application request and approval workflow
Establish regular application review schedule

Ongoing Maintenance Tasks¶

Weekly review of new application requests
Monthly audit of token authorizations
Quarterly review of application inventory
Semi-annual security assessment of critical applications
Annual comprehensive application rationalization

Resources and Documentation¶

Appendix: Application Security Assessment Template¶

MARKETPLACE APPLICATION SECURITY ASSESSMENT

Application Name:
Developer:
Application Type: [ ] OAuth App [ ] Add-on [ ] Chrome Extension [ ] Apps Script

REQUESTED PERMISSIONS
- Gmail: [ ] Read [ ] Modify [ ] Full Access
- Drive: [ ] Read [ ] Modify [ ] Full Access
- Calendar: [ ] Read [ ] Modify [ ] Full Access
- Admin: [ ] Read [ ] Modify [ ] Full Access
- Other: _____________________________

SECURITY EVALUATION
Developer Reputation: [ ] Unknown [ ] Limited History [ ] Established [ ] Google Verified
Last Updated: _______________
User Base Size: _______________
Security Features: [ ] Encryption [ ] Data Minimization [ ] Limited Scopes [ ] Other: _______

RISK ASSESSMENT
Data Access Risk: [ ] Low [ ] Medium [ ] High
Integration Risk: [ ] Low [ ] Medium [ ] High
Organizational Impact: [ ] Low [ ] Medium [ ] High
Overall Risk Score: [ ] Low [ ] Medium [ ] High

RECOMMENDATION
[ ] Approve for Organization
[ ] Approve with Restrictions: _____________________________
[ ] Approve for Specific OUs: _____________________________
[ ] Deny
[ ] Additional Review Required: _____________________________

APPROVAL INFORMATION
Reviewed By: _______________
Date: _______________
Expiration/Review Date: _______________

Note: This guide should be adapted to your organization's specific Google Workspace configuration, security requirements, and operational needs.